How is Hotel Brummell rated?

Hotel Brummell scores 9.3/10 on Booking.com and 4.7/5 on Google.

How many guest reviews were analysed for Hotel Brummell?

HotelShortlist analysed 500 guest reviews for Hotel Brummell to build this verified profile.

Is Hotel Brummell a 4-star hotel?

Yes — Hotel Brummell is a 4-star property in Barcelona.

How do I get the member rate?

HotelShortlist is a private members’ club. Ask for an introduction and, once admitted, member rates are unlocked on every verified hotel.

Assessment visible · Rates members only

HotelShortlist rating

4/5

On the HotelShortlist, with a caveat: Guests report hidden fees.

Barcelona

Hotel Brummell

Name: Hotel Brummell
Address: Barcelona

★★★★

9.3

Booking score

4.7

Google rating

828

Total reviews

★★★★

Star rating

≈2015

Built / renovated

Highest floor guests reported

Noise mentions

Engine scores ·Newness ≈2015 ·Location 4.7

Member rate

€—,———

Booking.com shows the public rate for the same room and dates

Members see this rate in full. It is typically lower than the public price on this property — the same room, the same hotel, the same confirmation.

Ask for an introduction Already a member? Sign in

Verdict

Is Hotel Brummell Worth It? The Honest Verdict

9.3/10 Booking.com4.7/5 Google500 reviews read4-star

As of 5 October 2026, 500 guest reviews give Hotel Brummell 9.3/10 on Booking.com and 4.7/5 on Google.

Most-repeated praise: Exceptionally warm, personalized staff who go above and beyond with restaurant recommendations, local tips, and making guests feel like family rather than transactions 87 reviews.

Complaints

Noise and Room Complaints at Hotel Brummell: Which Rooms to Avoid

Breakfast service staff were rude and unprofessional, complaining when guests requested second cups of coffee and making them feel unwelcome
Multiple operational failures on important bookings including cancelled reservations without proper explanation, poor communication, and staff hanging up on callers
Outdoor bathtub in penthouse advertised as amenity but non-functional in winter months due to low water temperature and poor drainage/sealing 3 reviews

Rooms to avoid

Street-facing rooms can have late-night carousing noise that dies down quickly
Pool-side/terrace rooms may hear brunch/restaurant noise during daytime weekend service

What guests praise

Hotel Brummell Reviews — What Guests Actually Say vs the Marketing

Hotel Brummell sells itself as a 4-star hotel. What guests repeat most:

Exceptionally warm, personalized staff who go above and beyond with restaurant recommendations, local tips, and making guests feel like family rather than transactions 87 reviews
Beautiful, thoughtfully designed boutique aesthetic with attention to every detail from room furnishings to lobby art, creating a stylish and cohesive experience 62 reviews
Outstanding breakfast featuring fresh pastries from Funky Bakers, excellent coffee, and generous assortments of quality cheeses, meats, and fruits 45 reviews

Room requests

Which Room Should You Ask For at Hotel Brummell?

Ask for

Upper floor rooms quieter than lower floors
Mountain-view rooms (facing Montjuïc) quieter than street-facing rooms
Penthouse suites quieter and more private

Method

How HotelShortlist Researched Hotel Brummell

We read 500 public guest reviews of Hotel Brummell, grouped repeated findings and counted how often each one appears. Pest figures are guest reports, not inspection results. Member-only detail is blurred on this page. Research updated 2026-10-05. If you represent Hotel Brummell and believe something here is wrong, write to members@hotelshortlist.com and we will review it.

What guests love

Exceptionally warm, personalized staff who go above and beyond with restaurant recommendations, local tips, and making guests feel like family rather than transactions (87×)

Beautiful, thoughtfully designed boutique aesthetic with attention to every detail from room furnishings to lobby art, creating a stylish and cohesive experience (62×)

Outstanding breakfast featuring fresh pastries from Funky Bakers, excellent coffee, and generous assortments of quality cheeses, meats, and fruits (45×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full(79×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full (38×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members s(44×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see th(31×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Mem(41×)

5 more positive findings visible to members.

Watch-outs · 8 recorded

Breakfast service staff were rude and unprofessional, complaining when guests requested second cups of coffee and making them feel unwelcome (1×)

Multiple operational failures on important bookings including cancelled reservations without proper explanation, poor communication, and staff hanging up on callers (1×)

Outdoor bathtub in penthouse advertised as amenity but non-functional in winter months due to low water temperature and poor drainage/sealing (3×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see th (2×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see th (1×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in fu (1×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding i (1×)

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full M (1×)

5 more watch-outs are visible to members.

Parking note. Problematic — Parking nearby is expensive and discount codes don't always work; hotel recommends using public transport instead.

What guests report

View

Mountain view rooms (Montjuïc) and street-facing rooms are quieter and more desirable; penthouse rooms have city/mountain views

Bed & mattress

High-quality, very comfortable, exceptionally soft; guests praise mattress quality consistently

Bathroom & water

Excellent water pressure, good hot water, rainfall shower, heated bathroom floors in some rooms; very spacious in penthouse suites

Wi-Fi

Good reliability and speed; suitable for video calls with screen sharing

Breakfast

Excellent quality with fresh pastries from Funky Bakers, local cheeses/meats, fruits; worth booking; coffee is exceptional

AC / heating

Works very well in rooms; some guests reported rooms running warm in evening hours

Elevator

Available

Local knowledge

Book directly through their website to get 50% off bike rental for a half day; staff happy to arrange

Request upper floor rooms for better views and less street noise

The outdoor bathtub in penthouse rooms only works in summer; cold/non-functional in November-March

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Me

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in

Members see the full detail. Ask for an introduction

Room intel

Quiet rooms / wings

Upper floor rooms quieter than lower floors
Mountain-view rooms (facing Montjuïc) quieter than street-facing rooms
Penthouse suites quieter and more private

Noisy rooms to avoid

Street-facing rooms can have late-night carousing noise that dies down quickly
Pool-side/terrace rooms may hear brunch/restaurant noise during daytime weekend service

Extra charges guests were surprised by

Members see this finding in full Members see this finding in full M
Members see this finding in full Members

Members see the full detail. Ask for an introduction

Character & facilities

Design & character 12% of reviews mention design

Boutique aesthetic with thought-given-to-every-detail; boho-organic feel
Minimalist modern design with colorful accents and beautiful painted tiles
Stunning architecture and layout; design-forward hotel celebrated as 'design lover's haven'

Gym & fitness Basic

Free yoga classes offered next door through Beyond Barcelona partnership (midweek schedule)
Sauna available 24/7 (requires 30 minutes advance notice)
No dedicated gym room mentioned; emphasis on wellness/yoga rather than weight training

You are reading research nobody publishes.

This assessment is one of 200+ across 25+ cities. Members also see the rate — and book it. Membership is by introduction; if you found your way here, tell us who you are.

Ask for an introduction