How many hotels in Jamaica has HotelShortlist verified?

5 hotels in Jamaica have been through the HotelShortlist review-analysis process, based on 1,364 guest reviews.

What is the highest-rated verified hotel in Jamaica?

Paradise Point Company Limited currently holds the highest Booking.com score (9.4/10) among verified hotels in Jamaica.

How do I get member rates in Jamaica?

HotelShortlist is a private members’ club. Ask for an introduction; admitted members see the member rate on every verified hotel.

Best hotels in Jamaica: 5 researched

5 verified hotels · 1,364 guest reviews analysed · data refreshed 2026-10-04

Jamaica Hotels by the Numbers

As of 4 October 2026, HotelShortlist has read 1,364 guest reviews of 5 hotels in Jamaica.

Hotels researched: 5
Guest reviews read: 1,364
Median Booking.com score: 9.2/10
Median Google score: 4.7/5
Average share of positive reviews: 100%
Hotels with at least one guest pest report: 0 of 1 checked
Met the HotelShortlist bar: 1 of 5

Pest figures are guest reports found in the reviews we read, not inspection results.

Full dossiers — every review analysed

Paradise Point Company Limited

★★★★ · Booking 9.4 · Google 4.9 · 27 reviews read

Guests love: Staff and owners demonstrate exceptional warmth, genuine care, and attentiveness that goes far beyond standard hospitality, with guests frequently naming individuals like Dacia, Zady, and Lorna who follow up personally and handle special requests with enthusiasm

Read the full dossier →

Also assessed in Jamaica

Strawberry Hill ★★★★ Booking 9.0
Geejam ★★★★ Booking 9.2
The Cliff Hotel ★★★★ Booking 9.1
Maribella@Crystal Cove Ocho Rios ★★★★ Booking 9.2

Researched Hotels in Nearby Cities

Questions about Jamaica hotels

How many hotels in Jamaica has HotelShortlist verified?: 5 hotels in Jamaica have been through the HotelShortlist review-analysis process, based on 1,364 guest reviews.
What is the highest-rated verified hotel in Jamaica?: Paradise Point Company Limited currently holds the highest Booking.com score (9.4/10) among verified hotels in Jamaica.
How do I get member rates in Jamaica?: HotelShortlist is a private members’ club. Ask for an introduction; admitted members see the member rate on every verified hotel.